Oil Bear

The price of oil is going down.

The resilience of oil prices in the face of an onslaught of grim economic and political developments around the world implies supply is currently quite tight. But don’t be fooled by oil over $100: The energy market is about to be turned on its head, and it’s all about shale.

A rather lax regulatory regime (courtesy messrs Bush and Cheney) has led to rapid exploration, immense investment in technology and huge increases in estimates of US shale energy reserves. It is quite likely that in a matter of years the US will shift from being an oil importer to an exporter – with interesting consequences for the global economy and political ecosystem. The percentage of US oil that’s imported has dropped from 60% during Bush’s second term to under 45% now.

As a sign of how fast reserves are being discovered, in 2011 the US Energy Information Administration more than doubled its estimate of technically recoverable shale gas reserves to 827 trillion cubic feet (for a sense of scale, in 2010 the US consumed about 24 trillion cubic feet). This is not the sort of thing that would lead to an increase in global energy prices.

The consequences within the industry are no less dramatic. Currently most oil in the US is travels South from the oil sands in Canada – with a production cost of around $80 per barrel. The cost of producing a barrel of shale oil is around $60, with some fields potentially as low as $40 – Royal Dutch Shell announced it could produce in Colorado at $30 a barrel. The numbers themselves tell the story. Once these fields pumping at full capacity, higher cost producers are up the creek, so to speak. Since they’ll have already made huge fixed investments they will have to keep pumping, as even producing at a loss would be better than idling the wells and losing more. The result will be disaster for the weaker capitalised and vast profits for the shale producers.

The impact will be far more broadly felt than that. Cheap energy, the lifeblood of industry, is exactly what the world needs right now. Cash saved on petrol is cash left sitting in all of our wallets. Every industry relies on the price of energy, so lower prices would be a boon to all. Traditionally periods of low energy prices have corresponded with booms (think 1970s vs late 90s), while the mid-2008 oil spike is arguably the most under-estimated causes of the sharp recession that followed. Perhaps this could be the boost to growth that the global economy is lacking right now. Hope so.

A good way to play it would be on the futures curve. Selling 12-18 months forward would have better risk-reward – the price will respond less sharply to any positive oil shocks while a clever move would be to cover the position by selling long-term puts around $50-60, or higher, giving you a much wider range of profitable scenarios. I’ll post later on specific long-short equity plays that also make sense.

Now there are obviously darker consequences to cheaper energy, most obviously the effect higher consumption has on global warming. There are also concerns over the health, safety and environmental impact of harvesting shale. The process involves pumping oceans of water underground, which ominously appears to increase local seismic activity, while there are (perhaps a little hysterical) concerns gas could enter the water supply, with a video of tap water igniting recently going viral. These concerns, magnified by higher population densities, have left Europe years behind in developing the legal and technical structures to make use of their own vast reserves. Whether these fears play out and the US slams the break on shale development is impossible to discern, though a health disaster in the headlines would probably have more impact than simmering environmental concerns, valid though they may be. But with whole continents stagnating and no end yet in sight to the crisis, almost into its fifth year, it would be a foolish politician who wasted this potential windfall.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Oil Bear”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s